"Would you like a coke with your product-sandwich?"

How many times have you been asked the above question at your local wine store?

"Huh?" you say.... okay, so maybe you weren't asked the question explicitly... instead it was embedded in the array of differently priced wines displayed throughout the shop.

For those of you who, like me, know little about wine, when was the last time you went into a wine store and bought the cheapest wine on the shelf? When was the last time you bought the most expensive wine on the shelf? My guess is that most of you can't recall the last time you did either because when you go to the wine store you "play it safe" and usually buy a wine priced "somewhere in the middle". I know I do.

Little did you realize that your local wine store was employing a product-sandwich strategy, drawing you helplessly towards that mid-priced bottle of wine! And you thought you were in control! :)


What is a Product-Sandwich Strategy?
In a nutshell, the strategy involves creating/selling a (very) high-priced version of your product so that the next price down appears more moderate in comparison. Often times this "next price down" would be considered expensive by the customer in absolute terms, but in relative terms (i.e., next to your "Rolls Royce" model) it appears reasonably priced. If implemented successfully, the net impact on your business is a boon in sales of the mid-priced version.


Why does the Product-Sandwich Strategy work?
The Product-Sandwich strategy is based on the principle that when buying an unfamiliar product or service people tend to purchase a mid-priced version of it. Why? It all comes down to risk aversion - fear of making a bad purchase and flushing money down the toilet bowl. This toilet-bowl-infused aversion is the reason we shy away from the pricey models ("How much better could that stereo possibly sound?") and reject the cheap ones ("I bet this stereo would die after a month!").


Can I use a Product-Sandwich Strategy in my business?
Businesses that sell hard-to-value goods (e.g., perfume, body lotion, wine, caskets), or whose target customers tend to be product novices are generally best suited for a Product-Sandwich strategy.

• Think selling perfume to people who don't know the difference between eau de toilette and the water in their toilets.
  
• Or selling car oil to someone who doesn't happen to have a name embroidered on his shirt.

Make sure customers are made aware of the range of price points
One critical success factor for any product sandwich strategy is to ensure that your customers are aware of the different price points of your products, most notably your high-priced version. It is this awareness that leads your customers to view the mid-priced products as the mid-priced products, and hence the "safe, yet reasonable choice".


What do you think?
Have you ever employed a product-sandwich or similar such strategy? If so, how successful was it? What did you learn? What worked? What didn't work?

What ethical issues, if any, does this bring up for you? Do you view this as psychological manipulation or just good, plain marketing strategy?

Please share your experiences, comments, thoughts or questions.






Additional info sources on Product-Sandwich strategy & the psychology behind it

• Dan Gilbert's presentation at the TED Conference (podcast)
  

• Stumbling on Happiness (Dan Gilbert's great follow-up book to his TED talk)

• Yes!: 50 Scientifically Proven Ways to Be Persuasive

• Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion (Collins Business Essentials)

• Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness

...and for those who really hate wine stores & happen to have iPhones

• Reviews of iPhone wine apps
  

Grow or die! Product fertilizer to grow your top line

Apologies on the overly dramatic, “please-read-me!” title. I figured I’d jump into the pool with the rest of the bloggers attempting to get the attention of the 1.6 billion of you bouncing around the virtual world.

Anyhow, you’re probably familiar with the phrase, “whatever stops growing eventually dies”. And, while I don’t subscribe to this black & white, morbid declaration, we all know that when it comes to your business, growth is essential.

So in the spirit of doing my little part to help get our economy back on its feet, I’ve decided to write a series of brief articles about different growth drivers (tools, frameworks) you can use to grow your products & your business, and perhaps even add a few inches to your height. So let’s get started…


Growth driver #1: develop different versions of your product to suit different usage scenarios

Take mustard. Yes, mustard.

You’re at a baseball game with some friends. Perhaps you’ve enjoyed a few beers. You head out to one of the fine stadium restrooms to reduce your inner-bladder pressure, and you decide to pick up a hotdog on your way back to your seat. Guldens, right? The perfect neon-yellow goo to spread on your ‘dog. No questions asked. Right place, right time. Guldens all the way.

Flash forward 2 months. You find yourself at a very formal cocktail party. Pinkies out, fancy degrees flying about, drinks you would otherwise never drink, people doing their best to inject British-inflexions. You make your way over to the hors d'oeuvre table and sample a selection of finely smoked meats. Grey Poupon, anyone? Again, no questions asked. Right place, right time. It’s a Grey Poupon moment.

(sorry, I just couldn't help but include the most classic Grey Poupon commercial ever produced. enjoy!)



Let's put aside the mustard and put growth driver #1 to work for you:
1. Make a list of the different situations in which your product or service is used (or needed).

2. For each scenario you’ve identified, jot down those characteristics or dimensions that make it different from the other scenarios on your list. Characteristics could include the physical environment, the people you’re with, your main objective at the time you use the product, your main reason for needing the product, the time of year, the activity you’re engaged in at the time you need the product, etc.

3. For each scenario ask yourself what changes you could make to your service in order to provide greater value to your customers given the unique characteristics of the situation.

Examples could include adding complementary services, increasing or decreasing the performance level of certain features or dimensions, adding or eliminating certain features, making changes to physical dimensions of the product, etc. Whatever you come up with, it should be dictated by the unique needs of your customer under the given scenario.

Real-world examples of growth driver #1. Different versions of the product for different usage occasions.

• Candles: For romantic dinners, for keeping the bugs away when camping, for festive holidays, for scenting the air, for birthdays.
• Travel insurance: For safaris, for ski trips, for family vacations, for cruises, for long-stay trips, for international trips.
• Suits: For hot climates, for formal events, for casual events, for outdoor events, for weddings, for funerals.

What other examples can you think of? Please share them with us in your comments.

Happy growing!

-------

Additional posts that discuss growth strategies:

• Innoviation via other worlds: a tool for generating powerful ideas for your business
• Enhance your innovation by tapping your product's value-creation web

Great books that discuss scenario-based product innovation:

• Marketing Imagination, New, Expanded Edition 

• The Entrepreneurial Mindset: Strategies for Continuously Creating Opportunity in an Age of Uncertainty

• What Customers Want: Using Outcome-Driven Innovation to Create Breakthrough Products and Services
  

Your product's lemming factor: are you following your competitors off a cliff?

I have seen it happen time & time again... and it always reminds me of the psychology of crowds, and how the individuals within the crowds assume their fellow crowd-members know something they don't know. So the individual continues to follow the crowd, all the while not realizing that the crowd is often an amalgam of equally confused individuals...

The Lemming Effect
Ok, enough of the philo-babble. The "lemming effect" as I call it is no doubt present within many organizations, and all of us at one time or another fall into its trap. Its influence within product management & product development is pervasive, frequently resulting in products that get bulkier & costlier over time. But we would be remiss to equate the proliferation of bells, whistles & "performance enhancers" with greater levels of customer value.

There are many drivers of the phenomenon of "Frankensteining" a product, and the lemming effect is at the top of the list. It all starts when we become more focused on our competitors than on our customers. One day Acme, our arch rival, increases the performance of its product or adds a new feature. "Hmmm", we think to ourselves, "What does Acme know that we don't? Are customers demanding greater levels of performance?" And then, voila, with limited thought or analysis we quickly 'upgrade' our product. Acme no doubts catches wind of our "2.0", and the arms race ensues.

All the while, our customers might not even be looking for the increased performance or the new bell or whistle. Perhaps our target customer looks a little different from Acme's target customer, and have somewhat differing needs. Perhaps Acme's reason for making enhancements to its product were ill-conceived or driven by internal factors that are invisible to us. Regardless of the reason, the one thing we have successfully achieved is increasing the cost of both our product as well as Acme's, who will no doubt follow suite with their "3.0". Whether we're able to "pass along" this incremental cost to our customers in the form of higher prices is something we certainly hope we can do.

Never take your eyes off your customers
The moral of the above faux situation, and of the lemming effect in general is to be wary of the moves that your competitors make. Do not assume the moves they are making are the right ones or that they have generated an insight that has given them the secret to building the perfect service for customers. The remedy to the lemming effect is quite straightforward, yet often ignored. Stay abreast of what your competitors are doing, but keep your eye on the ball - aka, your customers! Stay close to your customers. Develop multiple channels & methods for gaining access to the "voices of your customers". Understand their needs, desires, motivations, decision-making processes, changes in their outlooks or needs, etc. If you do these things right, you will be far less vulnerable to the lemming instinct, and far more confident in product decisions that you choose to make.